T O P

What Undead Nightmare 2 could have looked like (both for online and story)

What Undead Nightmare 2 could have looked like (both for online and story)

H0vis

Monster hunting would be so much better than zombies. Although zombies would be easier so handy as well. It's kind of a problem with RDO/GTAO that they are a *somewhat* low fantasy setting. You have aliens, you have ghosts, but you don't really have enough there that you could go all Weird West and have the players set up as full time supernatural creature hunters. Although it would be spectacular if they did. With a few tricks of lighting and whatnot you could turn huge swathes of the map into positively terrifying locations for legendary bounty style monster hunts.


VersedFlame

This is why most of us would want Undead Nightmare 2. Undead Nightmare basically was a whole new Red Dead Redemption 1 campaign but based around zombies and supernatural stuff. Just imagine Undead Nightmare 2 as a different launcher for RDR2, that would have a fantasy/horror campaign, and in multiplayer you could choose whether to go to normal online or undead online, in which you could maybe preserve some people making a somewhat normal living and some normal missions while at the same time having creatures roaming in the wild and also supernatural missions like tracking vampires, hunting witches and monsters... I reckon it'd be awesome to play such things coop with friends, for example a mission where the Saint Denis population is terrified by an enormous wolf roaming the streets, there are dead bodies around the streets, streets are smeared with blood, you can see and hear some people scared and running to get to their homes, and your job is to track and take down the creature. God that would be awesome, now I wish I hadn't thought that deep into it because Rockstar won't go so far.


lord_dude

I would love undead nightmare 2 in online. But now imagine Arthur or John reacting to the horror, man that would be so fucking awesome.


VersedFlame

Both is the ideal.


Esbarse

*ghostly* Lenny!


ThefaceX

about saint denis, if keep your hears open you can hear some npc talking about the fact that apperently there is a vampire in saint denis, with the halloween update they could make this true, they never will, but they could


BrilliantBaboon

There is one in campaign at least


ThefaceX

yeah, at least singleplayer is great


VersedFlame

It is true, it's there on the story mode and it gives you a special knife iirc. Still, like I said, a mode dedicated to that kind of stuff would be so cool, especially on coop with friends.


phenomenation

They could give us silver bullets and melee, different tonics for defense against certain creatures, and give us monster hunting drip. The end tier BH role outfit is a good example of Van Helsing vibes. It could be *so great*. It just… won’t happen.


ONECOOLCAT0

With gta your idea just made me think of supernatural. Lol


TenTonsOfAssAndBelly

Shout out to Weird West. Not a bad game


Lesbian-Turtle

“You eat babies”


LadyLikesSpiders

We eat berries! And mushrooms, you fool!


Usagi_Aka

The other other white meat


ziggy9-

I LOVE this. This is amazing. Ty for the post


tropical-swish

This guy has gave me more than R\* has in 3 years...


Dixons05

This would be cool maybe as a legendary bounty or something. It would be too much wishful thinking to expect r* to put them into free roam lol


gouchedscotsman

A supernaturalist update would be a good extension for the naturalist role 😅


DamonFort

I'd expect to see a lot of people cosplaying the Winchesters if you could be a supernaturalist 🤣


Getdunkled

“Dean?!” “Sam-AY!!”


ICECOLD1776

Yeah but i hate harriet so ill never get to do it


gouchedscotsman

Yeah, would be a good thing for gus to provide us.


ClappedCorn

I agree but for a different reason. I hate to bring it up but when I used to play fortnite and they added zombies all around the map it was horrible because I couldn’t go about my business without being attacked by some. Imagine how terrifying this would be in free roam while your just trying to mess around with friends, collect collectibles or deliver trader goods or moonshine. It would be an amazing legendary bounty or naturalist update though. Imagine walking away from gus wearing a garment set of one of these creatures.


lipp79

That’s why it would only be a a couple weeks long event.


Crimson_Carp748

Thanks for this... The concept looks great but they're far too lazy to put this stuff in the game


snieves0426

Oh I know they are. I really did a thanos moment when I made this and I was like *fine, I’ll do this myself*


3DogsInATrenchcoat

They're not lazy, they don't support the game because there aren't nearly as many players as GTAO.. Because they don't support the game. Perfectly reasonable


DancingBabyChalupa

The skin crawler could be used for random encounters like the one where you get ambushed, but instead of a person and their posse jumping you they turn into their monster form and rip you in half or something.


heythatsprettygood11

ahhh if only gta online didn't exist


Moofooist765

I mean if it didn’t RDR2 would probably be a barrel of shit in comparison to how it is now.


heythatsprettygood11

probably


Zek177

Dont agree GTAO money is the reason R games are going to get amazing levels in quality. They always were the best but I think the power of GTAO money will make GTA6 godlike


KingdomOfPoland

GTAO is a necessary evil for further great (story) Masterpieces


Zek177

Exactly


bonefistboy9000

bad mindset


Zek177

Explain ? Its not a mindset if its true lol where do you think all that GTAO money will go ?


bonefistboy9000

in the pockets of the ceos. like it always does.


Zek177

Yeah dude always ... Games are made free.


heythatsprettygood11

yeah I see what you're saying as long as we get gta 6 the next three years


Zek177

Even if its longer than that money will be there GTAO still makes great cash ! Though I think there is no way they arent working on GTA6 after RDR2


Tha_Sly_Fox

Agreed. Seed money for the armies of developers it takes to make these games (which regardless of online are both masterpieces) and also incentivizes Take2/Rockstar to keep pushing the games


Crackpixel

Well if GTA itself didn't exist i wouldn't know wich Wild West World we would be discussing about lel. Im kinda too old for the GTA Online Stuff (legit over a thousand hours in GTA IV, just cruising around lol). We had our own thing that was called the glitches bitches. I took the helicopter put us on any high house and then we had to ragdoll glitch us down. If you landed a certain way or angle you survived big falls. Nobody did that, NOBODY we were the king of the glitches bitches, still over 10 years later, we are the Glitches Bitches. (Obviously a few stunt videos came close to the glitches bitches theory (big falls no or minimal dmg, but they were different)). Stands forever man. Full speeded energy drink 15y olds, we were unstopable lol. Sorry for that nonsense text, no idea were i went there but tl:dr= We have RDO because of the good GTA Days, and we wont... actually Rockstar wtf man please stop you are hurting me with this doing nothing stuff. Not sure what cool things are in pipeline but it cant be the new reality that we get no dlc, and close to no content, the game is old aready man ffs. I still enjoy RDO every week, but man so many possibilities. Looks like this is ranting once you start going old. Real tl:dr= It hurts.


heythatsprettygood11

thanks for sharing your glory days and I 100% agree that there are so many possibilities but none of them happen


sammeadows

-shudder- anything but the Jackalope...


Extra_Degree_7236

I LOVE how Sasquatch is universally recognized because of that one silly “who me?” Pose walking. I love it


ottoDVD

Too good for the today R*.


lostnote6621888

I want a mothman coat now


EpyonComet

Tracking vampires through the streets and alleys of Saint Denis would honestly be cool as hell.


Seco2600

That fifth one doesn’t eat babies, they eat herbs and berries!


Sverker_Wolffang

I'm surprised that you didn't include draugr near Annesburg due to sll the viking stuff in the area.


anti-peta-man

Add Skincrawlers and Wendigos for ultimate Pants shitting


PYROxSYCO

Incendiary ammo aquired!


forcedhammerAlt

These look dope. Some should only be reached if you climb certain tricky mountains (and some can only be killed with new types of plant oil infused arrows etc)


FoxSaint

Hunting cryptids is what naturalist could have been


bigchungybailey

I think it would be cool also if it turns out the post guy at van horn was actually a friendly vampire that were able to give you these kinds of missions to hunt them down.


_BlueTinkerBell_

Seeing a wendigo or skinwalker a at night in the swamp would give me a heart attack


Stoney_Chan69

Bruh I was treasure hunting in blackbone forest during the night and fuck the ambiet sounds are freaky asf


ThefaceX

this makes me wish for a game where we hunt folklore monsters like werewolves and shit


PYROxSYCO

The hunt: Showdown


orangescionxb

Agreed 👍🏻


Conar13

Bravo! Looks great bud


slingtheory

With all those ufo references in the main story I thought a cowboy and aliens story would've been a cool idea


Cl4ymist3r

This is brilliant concept! If only man, if only...


VersedFlame

If only Rockstar would actually do this. Looks amazing.


fucknametakenrules

Be awesome to have a wendigo in tall trees or in the mountains and have the skin Walker near the native reserve


rlo1596

Just give me Arthur killing zombies for 10 hours story line god dammit.


STerrier666

Number 18 was Nessie on holiday, it wasn't as quiet as she thought it would be.


Farcryfan15

Lol I think the bayou in and around saint denis is creepy enough at night without having a skunk ape roaming around.


D34DLYH4MST3R

The photo for "the walker" is one of the wendigos from until dawn lol, still a really cool idea though


psycodull

Supernatural bounty hunter


_Veprem_

A permanent Undead Nightmare lobby with Monster Hunting + Ambient Zombies is what we need.


voidmasterabyss

I would love a mode where you deal with supernatural beings. You can also somewhat become one and they have benefits but also weaknesses. Vampires: Drinking blood will replenish your stamina, and you’re stronger and faster than normal. Careful of hunters. After a home ownership expansion you can buy coffins to sleep in Werewolf: Based on Loup Garou you are a stronger version of the vampire but EVERY policeman will actively hunt you and the hunters are even more after you. You transform on full moon. Becomes a horror game.


MartoPolo

Vampires vs Werewolfs, a timeless classic and not overused


PYROxSYCO

Wait! I got other ideas! Hunt down escapees from Hell for "The Stranger" and bring them in like bounties. Capture living people who sold there soul and their time is up. Horde mode with a twist! Survive an army of zombies and ghouls from demented swamp witch with the power of Voodoo! Zombies are quick but ghouls carry guns and shoot inaccurately while slowly walking to you. Complete the "Heist to Hell" Rob the mysterious "black train of hell" and save a fallen angel! Loot gold, valuables, cash, and treasures from the train before it reaches it's final fiery destination! But beware, those tickets masters are going to punch your ticket if you careful! What do you guys think?


Franklymrshankl

Technically wolfman wouldn't be undead.


snieves0426

Sasquatch, the Chupacabra, and the Jackalope aren’t undead either and they were all in undead nightmare


Franklymrshankl

It was so long ago... I remember the Chupacabra mission. I'm not saying wolfman is a bad idea.


OgiimaWJY

Why the fuck did you use a picture of a actual Wendigo and call it a crawler ? That is literally how the Wendigo has been described for thousands of years not that weak ass zombie elk you said was a wendigo


snieves0426

Dude… I said it was a STYLIZED WENDIGO in the captions… my god can you read?


Synner1985

Didn't you already post this once this week? or are you reposting someone elses idea? ​ I'm sure I've seen this as i thought it was an outstanding idea.


snieves0426

I did, but I tried crossposting to this one and just decided to repost it with more detailed captions.


__TB12__

What happened to rockstar :(. They used to make the best singleplayer games of all time and make great DLC. Too greedy with GTAO to give a damn about RDR2 and scrapped all DLC plans for the game smh. The first red dead was amazing and undead nightmare 2 was practically a great game on its own. It’s a shame how far rockstar has fallen


Rexli178

Some of these absolutely should never go in the game. The Wetiko and the Skinwalker are big deals in Algonquin and Navajo Cultures. To the point that there are Algonquin who to this very day will not break the taboo on Wetiko and the Navajo flat out will not talk about Skinwalkers with people who are not Navajo. These spirits and beliefs are really big deals to the cultures they originate from and should not be treated lightly. And Rockstar has not had a good track record with indigenous representatives. While Red Dead Redemption 2 is better than the first it still has problems.


snieves0426

I’m native myself, 80% Native American actually. I have no problem with having those cryptids in the game as long as they’re stylized. There’s nothing wrong with it, and they would make an amazing addition to undead nightmare


SuperArppis

Pretty cool that someone can go, find the beast and make guesses what does this beast weight and what it's height. 😁


sudev29

This is dope but Rockstar is never gonna put this much effort into their game.


north_korea_nukes

Would be awesome! Branch breaks in the woods. “That’s a Sasquatch!” Matt moneymaker voice. I’ll make my character look like Bobo. Jackelope mission all day!


ThePlanWasALie

Imagine the mission about hunting the lake monster. I like to imagine that Undead Nightmare 2 would keep the gang together (Maybe even have Micah be the first zombie victim so we don't have to deal with him), so imagine Dutch being like "Arthur, son. We're going fishing!"


SneakySnakeySnake

The chupacabra was only a thing in the 90s in Puerta Rick and then dumbasses in the states started killing dogs with mange because they thought it was the legend, even though the original was reptilian in nature


DANPARTSMAN44

this would be awesome .. the hair on the back of my neck stood up just thinking about this


Taken_name1243

Random but imagine a wendigo that can be found in the grizzlies mountains during thunderstorms


The7Reaper

This would have been awesome, they could have done each one like the Witcher Contracts in Witcher 3, such a missed opportunity.


Crippinbarbie

How bout incorporate this Bigfoot = tall trees Dogman=cumberland forest Wendigo=colter ambarino are wapiti The rake=roanoke The vampire=saint denis like story mode Legendary monstrous catfish= new austin river Goatman=somewhere in lemoyne Slenderman=blackwater are armodilla Abominable snowman= ambarino mountains Jersey devil=roanoke are annesburg Mothman=grizzlies east Hell hounds = heartlands Chupacabra= new austin Thunderbirds= wapiti are near wapiti Kondahar giant=mount hagan Mapinguari=roanoke valley Megalodon =sinking boats crossing carrying prisoners to the prison island on the big river by saint denis an terrorizing boats trying to dock in saint denis Are we can get honey flavored discounted beans


Philbin27

In order to hunt the Monster of Flat Iron Lake, it should cost 3.5 gold to activate via a note in your bag, and Monster bait, to lure it out of the water should cost $3.50. Payout for capture alive is 7 gold, dead 3.5.


Crackpixel

Imagine if your company is too big and bloated to add some funny halloween features wich would take 5 team members 2-3 months to prepare. Yeah imagine being thaaat BIG. Must be great hahah.


YEETUSDELETUS6ix9ine

I would be most excited for wendigos, such weird insane stories coming from them.


Izenthyr

This would have been so fucking awesome. One can only imagine how this would play out.


SpartanRage117

For some reason this makes me wonder what a Victorian Era R* game would look like with Van Helsing vampire hunter style shit. Come to think of it a medieval setting could be really interesting from R* if they fleshed out the hand to hand combat even more. Being a knight exploring the world on a Red Dead level horse sounds like a lot of fun.


Chefpief

These are fuckin cool.


Broda_osas360

Awesome post


StylinAndSmilin

I would like to see the mad scientist creating the Frankenstein creature near Van Horn actually bring it to life and you have to hunt it down.


snieves0426

SHOOT YES I FORGOT ABOUT THAT


Reddit-Book-Bot

Beep. Boop. I'm a robot. Here's a copy of ###[Frankenstein](https://snewd.com/ebooks/frankenstein/) Was I a good bot? | [info](https://www.reddit.com/user/Reddit-Book-Bot/) | [More Books](https://old.reddit.com/user/Reddit-Book-Bot/comments/i15x1d/full_list_of_books_and_commands/)


StylinAndSmilin

Good bot


suckashelfboi101

”You eat babies”


DoubleU159

This shit would be terrifying, I’d be shitting myself riding around in the middle of no where.


AggravatingMonk0429

At this point I'd even take a Call to Arms variant but make it zombies.


BuzzLightyearOP

Damnit, now i want all of this. Running for your life from the crawler in a series of caves would be nuts


Dale_theMan

While heavily unlikely this could still happen one day. Although it seems like they were leaving alien Easter eggs everywhere so it could be cowboys vs aliens.


LadyLikesSpiders

Ah yes, the New role for online: Witcher


NyoomNyoom656

Goddamn that’s some effort mate!


__something___

This is amazing! Maybe we could get missions about these creatures from the dude in the Valentine saloon from story. That could be a cool backstory for him


Spobobich

This would of been great! Can we all agree that RDO as it is currently is all we're gonna get from Rockstar? An online game that only caters to new players.


1895red

Wendigos wouldn't be found in Ambarino; they'd be further North and East, outside of the game's playable state analogues.


krik69

Supernaturalist role would be cool as hell, hunting demons, werewolves, vampires,ghosts and closing gates of hell like in supernatural, this would be the perfect setting for it. The colt with the special bullets that can kill anything would fit right in.


BRLY

I would’ve settled for more wolf-man sightings.


regulrpaste

Would be cool if you kill them, you could skin them and make clothing items with it, not like the legendary garment sets because it would look silly to have Dracula’s head on your head lol


forzenny

So much yes


eziokill911

Nah I would def love this


Lopsided_Nebula9288

They could be legendary monsters to hunt down, like legendary animals!


cpu101

I literally have a massive note on my phone about how I think a cryptid dlc should work. Like imagine a creepy ass npc that sells monster hunting tools (silver bullets, etc) and buys samples/parts. Maybe add the monsters to the naturalist animal log too. RDO would be perfect for monster hunting gameplay, I really hope they make something like it.


da_PeepeePoopooMan

Man I would absolutely LOVE this.


NovaPrismass

I was thinking about this yesterday while I was in emerald ranch taking pictures, I came across the post apocalyptic filter and thought about how perfect places like Emerald Ranch could be for an undead nightmare. Annesburg and a looming threat from the hills could be awesome too, or St Denis and the attack of the swamp people or night folk. Every town in this game is just about perfect for an undead nightmare scenario


SargentRy

This would be amazing. Such a disappointing waste of potential.


fingay-ren

Damn I’d love this, this is the sort of thing that I’d play for if it came out. But rockstar are kinda very boring...


sosigboi

This would honestly be awesome in that it gives me another reason to use my elephant gun and also make me feel like a monster hunter.


Icy_Law_9454

Having to hunt these and getting pelts and different clothes from it would be cool as fuck!


Dr_Wigglespank

The werewolves would be amazing. As a kid, I saw The Howling and American Werewolf in London, and I've been a big fan of werewolf movies since. Very few have come close to those two, though. The werewolves stand out, for me, but the others are very well done, too.


Libertyprime8397

This makes me sad. Thanks for that lol.


raspberryvodka

A Rougarou in RDR would make my whole life ;\_;


Llamalot

Better call Sam and Dean Lancaster.


TheMCM80

As long as they put in a ‘67 Impala hardtop so I can live out my Supernatural hunting fantasies.


gwarrior5

A gothic horror fantasy game from rockstar on the gta engine would be amazing. Carriages locomotives haunted houses and castles. Vampires hunters grave robbers mad scientists. It would be amazing.


Gathoblaster

This is perfect. At this point having an undead nightmare lobby with werewolves (as common as grizzly bears at night), vampires and more, Bounties for those folks instead of classic bounties ...


john-CG

If there was a “undead nightmare dlc type” man that would be great, just imagine it, arthur not as man against zombies, but rather as a van helsing type, or with one against classic horror monsters, and modern urban myths.


Ben-Be-chillin

What do you mean could have? Have they brought out info on undead nightmare 2?


FishMasterMemer

I really think for Roanoke Ridge or the Bayou, the Boogyman should have an appearance.


VenomShotX981

**AHEM** "the mothman of WEST Virginia"


Perfect_Music6802

I think that that mutant creature in that shack would be a cool thing to hunt in undead nightmare.


Tripconehead

Fighting a wendigo or a crawler in this game would be nuts. Really hope r* does that some day.


TheLastWhiteKid

Jackalope: Extremely Fast DO NOT APPROACH!


ValentinePatch1999

I’m convinced the white stag is a reincarnated Arthur


DarlingHades

I would love to see any of these!


OgiimaWJY

Wendigos don’t look like that lol


Eupatorus

So more of a Cyrptozoology Nightmare then, considering almost none of these are undead.


snieves0426

Sasquatch, the Chupacabra, and the Jackalope aren’t undead either… and they were in undead nightmare. Your point?


Eupatorus

The original Undead Nightmare was zombie based. This isn't, and therefore calling it Undead Nightmare 2 is a misnomer. That's my point. Beside the sasquatch is a R* tradition and has been in many of their games.


snieves0426

Zombies have been overdone to death, I’m sure rockstar if they ever decided to make an Undead Nightmare 2 would make it much different than the First one. Sure they’re could still be zombies, but I feel taking this approach and adding supernatural creatures would be a more creative and entertaining choice. The Rougarou for example is a classic werewolf if you look into the folklore behind it. Also, there is still 5 Undead things in this hypothetical I made. (The Wendigo, Skinwalker, Crawler, the white stag, and the Vampire) I’m sure if Rockstar did decide to do Undead Nightmare 2 they won’t leave out the zombies, but I did because I know for a fact that they would be in there and including them in this hypothetical would have been a wasted slot.


elpoopenator

Then that wouldnt be "Undead Nightmare"


snieves0426

Yes it would be. Lmaoooo, they’re still UNDEAD creatures in there, and zombies. Why the hell wouldn’t it be called undead nightmare 2? Cause zombies aren’t the main focus in this one? Lmao like I said they’ve been done to death and I’m sure rockstar would do something similar to what I did, especially since they added Bigfoot, The Jackalope, The Unicorn, and The Chupacabra to Undead Nightmare. Cryptids can be in it too, don’t know why you’d have a problem with that😂


Eupatorus

Wendigo are evil spirits and skinwalkers are traditionally witches. So they aren't even undead either. I dunno what this dude is on about.


snieves0426

I don’t know what your on about lmao😂


eq017210

You know Undead Nightmare had many more species other than undead s zombies right? They had a chupacabra, a unicorn, and the devil's goats While the original one had the jackalope, variety isn't something to complain of lol


ThefaceX

they don't even give us the possibility to fight against wolves and bears like in the singleplayer.....but it's nice to dream